August 4th 2013: Shades of 2007 in Commercial Real Estate?

Starting in 2007, commercial real estate (IYR) started vastly underperforming the ($SPX/SPY's).  Then, there was a big rebound off the March 2009 bottom after China bottomed in late 2008 with real estate leading, both in terms of relative performance and absolute returns.  And now we're seeing IYR leading to the downside again.

I like paying attention to price performance rather than opinions.  I'm sure there's lots of smart people jumping up and down and saying to buy or sell IYR right now based on some well-though-out, cogent arguments.  The trouble is that someone is wrong and I'm not clever enough to know which well-educated person is correct.  On the other hand, stock prices are always correct in the sense that they reflect matched prices for buyers and sellers at a particular moment in time, but I digress...

Here's what I see:  for whatever important reason, IYR is heading down and dramatically underperforming the SPY's as the SPY's are reaching all-time highs.  This week, not only did IYR fail to break out of a potential flag pattern, it broke down below MA support lines and the chandelier exit line.  In doing so, it appears headed for the bottom of the blue box @ $62.72.  If $62.72 should fail, there is a large inverse cup & handle bearish pattern which, if completed, would send prices much, much lower.  The only mild positives are that volume came in just above average and FORCE is still less than the June lows.

Good luck out there and may the FORCE index be with you in your trades.

For more charts and a disclaimer, please see my public chart list on stockcharts.com.

http://stockcharts.com/public/1109955